Jamie Redknapp has strongly criticized VAR’s quick dismissal of Kai Havertz’s penalty appeal during Arsenal's 2-0 victory over Everton, calling the decision "a disgrace." The incident, which occurred in the 23rd minute of the first half, saw Everton's Michael Keane make a clumsy challenge on Havertz inside the penalty area. Despite the clear foul, on-field referee Andy Madley did not award a penalty, and VAR official Stuart Attwell swiftly cleared the decision.
Clear Foul Ignored by Officials
As Havertz entered the box following a pass from Eberechi Eze, he was clearly impeded by Keane, who trod on the back of the Arsenal forward's foot. The challenge was significant enough to warrant a penalty, but the officials failed to take the necessary action. Sky Sports' co-commentator Alan Smith was left in disbelief, commenting that the referees had taken "so little time" to review the situation, especially given how clear the foul seemed.
Redknapp echoed this frustration during half-time, expressing shock at the speed with which VAR dismissed the appeal. "It's so clear. How on earth have VAR taken three seconds to say that's not a penalty?" he said. "That's a horrendous decision."
VAR's Quick Verdict Raises Concerns
The former footballer and pundit didn’t hold back in his criticism, highlighting the inconsistency of VAR decisions. Redknapp pointed out that there have been instances where decisions that were visibly incorrect took an extended period to review, but in this case, VAR's verdict was delivered almost immediately. "It's definitely a penalty and it should be overturned," Redknapp added. "We see VAR make decisions sometimes that everyone at home can see is not a penalty and it takes five minutes. They’ve taken three seconds to say it’s not a penalty. That is an absolute disgrace."
Arsenal Coaches Express Frustration
Following the controversial incident, Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta and several of his coaching staff were seen voicing their displeasure with the decision. They approached the fourth official, hoping to make their case for a potential penalty, but the decision stood. Despite the frustration, Arsenal went on to win 2-0, but the VAR controversy remains a topic of debate.
Redknapp’s comments reflect growing concerns over the use of VAR in the Premier League, with many questioning the consistency and transparency of its decision-making process.
